Why Am I Eating So Much? 15 Possible Explanations Using Psychology & Physiology

15 reasons why you feel like you're eating a lot - when you might not even be overeating in the first place

Whenever I find myself wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” the next question I like to ask is, “Was I hungry to begin with, and am I eating past fullness?” Because eating large amounts of food can indicate that your body needs fuel, or may indicate a medical issue, as you’ll soon see. If you’re eating past fullness in particular, it could indicate a psychological drive to eat beyond satiety.

Sometimes eating large amounts of food is simply due to biology. When you skip meals, for example, it is normal for the body to ask for plenty of fuel. However, when compulsive eating is involved, biology is often just one facet. While it’s still important, our psychology often accounts for the majority of the reasons why we eat past fullness.

This article digs into various biological and psychological reasons why you might be wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” — and how to navigate these moments of uncertainty.

Why Am I Eating So Much? Starting with the Basics

To help you identify the reason why you feel like you’re eating large amounts of food, we will start by digging into some light eating psychology. Then we’ll explore some essential medical disclaimers and finish with an even deeper exploration of eating psychology.

Here are the first places to check if you ever find yourself wondering, why am I eating so much?

1. You haven’t eaten enough throughout the day

Why am I eating so much? Not eating enough. if all you had for lunch was a salad, it could be the reason why you're craving lots of food

Not eating enough is the most frequent mistake I see as an eating psychology coach. When you skip meals and go for long periods of time without eating, your hunger may come strongly and suddenly.

If you are currently restricting calories or following a diet that limits your food intake, it could be the reason why you feel like you’re eating large amounts of food. Your body is getting much-needed and over-due fuel.

It’s also important to get an objective look at how much you’re eating too. What may appear as eating large amounts of food might actually be a normal amount of food. However, a culture obsessed with dieting has trained many of us to eat as little as possible; skewing our idea of what ‘normal eating‘ even is.

2. You skipped breakfast and/or lunch

Why am I eating so much? Skipping meals. not a breakfast person? make sure you're at least eating a proper lunch

If you want to lose weight, standard advice is to eat less than your body burns. However, in an attempt to speed up results, many of us end up eating far too little, and we end up binge eating as a consequence.

Skipping breakfast or lunch can be a trigger1 for binge eating. Your body works hard to keep you alive and this takes calories. Formally, this is known as your basal metabolic needs — aka, the number of calories required to sustain essential bodily functions while at rest.

When your body doesn’t get those calories from your diet, we like to think we use fat as fuel. This is what the ketogenic diet promises — but it is misguided at times. If you’re too stressed, your body actually prefers to use your muscles as fuel and it will slow down your metabolism2 so that you stop using as many calories.

3. You’re replacing food with coffee which is linked to binge eating

Why am I eating so much? Replacing breakfast with coffee. coffee is an appetite-suppressant, and it can lead to extreme hunger

Many of us are accustomed to “saving calories” by skipping meals or, even worse, having coffee instead. Coffee is linked to binge eating because of its appetite-suppressing qualities.3

Personally, when I drink coffee, I end up running around and accomplishing many tasks and errands — which is great — only for extreme hunger to hit as soon as the rush of energy wears off. I find myself wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” and then realize that I simply haven’t eaten enough.

Consume coffee with caution if you’re new to the idea of listening to your body to inform what you eat (instead of dieting). It’s hard to notice your hunger when your beverages are suppressing it.

4. You exercise at a high intensity

Why am I eating so much? Over-exercising. intense exercise is also an appetite-suppressant — try not to skip a post-workout meal even if you aren't hungry

Did you know that over-exercising can actually lead to overeating? Intense exercise can sometimes act as an appetite suppressant. This is highly debated4 in the medical community, so you’ll need to figure it out for yourself. After you work out, do you feel ravenous or is food off your mind?

And if you don’t eat after your workout, your hunger may come suddenly and trigger that moment of self-doubt: why am I eating so much? While it might feel like overeating, the truth is that you just worked out and your body needs fuel!

Whenever intense exercise is involved, it’s important to be kind to your body and nourish yourself with a variety of macronutrients (carbs, fats, and protein) after your workout.

5. You’re not eating enough dietary fat

Why am I eating so much? Lack of dietary fat. a lack of dietary fat can lead to a lack of satisfaction after a meal and continued hunger

Fat keeps us satisfied because it takes longer to digest and it helps stimulate the production of hormones5 that signal fullness. Eating too little fat causes us to crave more food to feel satisfied.

Therefore, if you find yourself wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” take a look at how much or how little dietary fat you’ve eaten — it could be the latter that’s triggering your appetite.

6. You’re stressed

Why am I eating so much? Too much stress. the stress hormone, cortisol, is known to increase your appetite for comfort foods

Stress is another trigger for overeating. It increases your appetite6 because the stress hormone, cortisol, increases hunger and food cravings. In particular, stress causes us to crave “hyperpalatable foods7 — aka, foods that are high in sugar, fat, carbohydrates, and/or salt.

Whenever you find yourself reaching for hyperpalatable food and eating large amounts of it, consider how much stress you’re dealing with. Then read-up on my tools to help cope with stress eating like the Stop, Drop, & Feel.

7. You’re dehydrated

Why am I eating so much? Dehydration. thirst can sometimes be confused for hunger, leading to feelings of hunger even after eating

Sometimes dehydration causes us to crave food even when we aren’t hungry because thirst can be confused for hunger.8 Personally, whenever I find myself craving fruit — and I’ve already had enough to eat throughout the day — I’m usually just dehydrated. Because as soon as I drink a cup of water, the craving for fruit goes away.

If the craving for fruit doesn’t go away once I’ve had water, I make sure to eat it. A fear of fruit is one of the ways that the popular ketogenic diet has created food aversions among the masses. When taken too far, it can spiral into an eating disorder known as Avoidant Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID).

8. You aren’t sleeping enough

Why am I eating so much? Lack of sleep. sleep plays a role in our hunger by regulating the appetite-stimulating hormone ghrelin

Although it may come as a surprise, sleep actually plays a role in our hunger by regulating the appetite-stimulating hormone ghrelin.9 Insufficient sleep has been shown to trigger higher levels of ghrelin10, which can increase your appetite when you are sleep deprived.

Next time you ask yourself, “Why am I eating so much?” check your sleep schedule. If you struggle with getting adequate shut-eye, it could be well worth a conversation with your doctor.

Why Am I Eating So Much? Looking at Medical Explanations

Before digging into the deeper psychological reasons behind the desire to overeat, it’s important to address a few more physiological causes first, because they are important. Here are some reasons to talk to your doctor if you’re concerned about eating lots of food:

9. You have a medical condition

Why am I eating so much? Medical conditions. diabetes and hyperthyroidism are two conditions that can increase hunger

Sometimes, a large increase in appetite signals a medical condition such as diabetes or hyperthyroidism. With diabetes, frequent hunger11 is a hallmark symptom; and with hyperthyroidism, the thyroid produces too many hormones, some of which regulate your appetite.12 Ask your doctor to screen you for any of these conditions, among others, for proper diagnosis and treatment.

10. It could be a side effect of medication

Why am I eating so much? Medication side effects. some medications, such as antidepressants, can stimulate hunger and motivate eating large amounts of food

Certain medication like insulin (for diabetes) or antidepressants are known to increase appetite. If you’re taking any medications, check the side effects for changes in appetite.

11. You could be pregnant

Why am I eating so much? Pregnancy. a dramatic increase in appetite is a hallmark symptom of pregnancy

Finally, it’s worth mentioning that a sharp increase in appetite could indicate pregnancy. If you find yourself wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” consider this possibility.

The Deeper Psychology Behind Why You’re Eating So Much

Now that we’ve sorted through the biological reasons for eating large amounts of food, let’s discuss the psychological reasons for overeating. To me, our psychology accounts for the majority of the reasons why we reach for food when we aren’t hungry.

Many of us are already aware of the biological reasons for eating large amounts of food. We got our thyroid tested, we get enough sleep, and we drink water. It can be even more frustrating, then, when you overeat anyway. Why am I eating so much when I’m doing everything right?

Here are some psychological triggers for eating large amounts of food:

12. You’ve become trained to think that normal amounts of food are too much

Why am I eating so much? Diet culture. you might *think* you're eating too much when you're actually eating a normal amount of food

Sometimes we feel like we’re ‘eating so much’ when the reality is that we’re eating normal amounts of food. This misconception can happen after many years of dieting and eating as little as possible.

Long-term dietary restrictions can cause us to forget our body’s actual needs for proper functioning. (Remember that phrase, basal metabolic needs, that I mentioned earlier?)

To help with this, I like to calculate how many calories I need to maintain my current weight. This is a good exercise for people recovering from chronic dieting, because many of us have no idea how much food we actually need for weight maintenance, not weight loss.

Check out the online calculator from NIDDK to roughly calculate how many calories you need for weight maintenance. You might be pleasantly surprised by how much you should be eating.

If this sounds unappealing because you would still like to lose weight, keep in mind that you can actually heal your metabolism by eating enough food, which can help you reach a healthy weight in the long-run.

13. You’ve been shamed out of eating regular, balanced meals

Why am I eating so much? Normalization of diet culture. chicken & broccoli is not a balanced meal because carbs are missing, but we have been trained to equate this with a “good” diet

If you ever attempted to lose weight by counting calories, it’s likely that you were taught that it was ‘good’ to skip breakfast because it helps ‘save calories’ for dinner. However, this makes you predisposed to eating large amounts of food later. Especially if you have a busy life, you will likely develop extreme hunger before you realize it.

However, many dieters will still opt for low-calorie options even when faced with extreme hunger. They may choose a chicken breast with broccoli, which is regarded by diet culture as ‘perfect eating;’ but in the face of extreme hunger, it does not provide the energy the body needs to function properly.

Not only does undereating slow your metabolism, but it perpetuates the restrict-binge cycle. You may find yourself wondering time and time again, “Why am I eating so much?” when your body is simply trying to communicate its need for sustenance and adequate food.

14. You’re overeating for emotional reasons

Why am I eating so much? Emotional eating. if you're eating lots of food *without hunger* it could indicate emotional eating

What if you find yourself eating enough food to meet your body’s needs but still struggle with the feeling of consuming too much? When you eat large amounts of food beyond the point of fullness, it could be a result of ‘avoidance eating,’ a type of emotional eating driven by the need to numb discomfort or unwanted emotions.

To address avoidance eating and put a stop to binge eating, the powerful Stop, Drop, & Feel method can be immensely helpful. When you experience the desire to eat without genuine hunger, it’s time to employ this approach.

how to stop a binge in its tracks with the Stop, Drop, & Feel®️
  • Step 1: Stop and pause when the impulse to eat without hunger Promise yourself that you can still eat what appeals to you after going through the Stop, Drop, & Feel process, if that is genuinely what you desire.
  • Step 2: Move to a different room, if possible, and set a timer for just two minutes. This is your opportunity to drop into your body and become aware of how you’re feeling. Approach your emotions with curiosity.
  • Step 3: Allow space for your emotions to coexist with you. Avoid intellectualizing or resisting them, as doing so may only intensify their strength. Instead, for two minutes, simply sit still with your most challenging emotions and truly feel them.

The effectiveness of the Stop, Drop, & Feel method lies in developing emotional awareness and emotional tolerance. By cultivating the ability to sit still with uncomfortable emotions, we build the resilience necessary to cope with our emotions without food.

15. You’re eating out of boredom

Why am I eating so much? Boredom eating. boredom is a secondary emotion, which means there's usually something else going on

We’ve all been in the grips of boredom eating at some point, mindlessly reaching for more food even though we aren’t hungry. But what many of us don’t realize is that boredom is a secondary emotion.

A secondary emotion is fueled by another emotion. From both my own experience overcoming binge eating and from coaching many others, it seems that the primary emotion behind boredom is usually some type of fear. It could be the ‘fear of missing out’ (FOMO) or the fear of falling behind. It is unique to everyone, but usually can be distilled down into some type of fear.

The good news is the Stop, Drop, & Feel is just as effective with boredom eating as it is with the other types of emotional eating. We just need practice turning our attention inward to develop the emotional awareness necessary.

The next time you find yourself wondering, “Why am I eating so much?” and you decide that it’s boredom eating, keep digging. Even if you don’t immediately stumble upon another emotion, practice with the Stop, Drop, & Feel can help you uncover more and more layers.

Steps to Navigate Periods of Eating Large Amounts of Food

Now that you know why you might feel like you’re eating ‘so much’ food sometimes, let’s talk about what you can do whenever that uncertainty arises. Although there were helpful tips sprinkled throughout this article, I think it’s nice to have them all listed together in the same place.

Here are some actionable steps to consider the next time you catch yourself wondering, why am I eating so much?

  • Evaluate your eating patterns: Are you skipping meals or going for long periods without eating? Are you eating a balanced diet with adequate nutrients, including enough healthy fats?
  • Ditch restrictive diets: Avoid falling into the trap of restrictive dieting, as it can lead to increased cravings, overeating, and obsessive thoughts about food. Do some research into the steps of giving up dieting and what happens after you stop dieting. It helps to be prepared.
  • Listen to your body: Pay attention to your body’s hunger and fullness cues, and honor them by eating when you’re genuinely hungry and stopping when you’re comfortably full. 
  • Heal your metabolism: If you’ve been restricting your diet and eating as little food as possible, it’s likely that your metabolism has adapted to your lifestyle. Fortunately, when you stop dieting and stop restricting your meals, you can begin the process of healing your metabolism.
  • Address emotional triggers: If you struggle with eating without hunger, start to use tools that directly address the emotions behind compulsive eating such as the Stop, Drop, & Feel
  • Engage in stress-reducing activities: Pick up meditation, intuitive movement, or talking to a supportive friend. Relaxation is key to developing a healthy relationship with food.
  • Seek professional guidance: If you continue to struggle with overeating or have concerns about your eating habits, consider reaching out to a qualified healthcare professional or an eating psychology coach. Providing yourself with extra support is a wonderful form of self-care.

Last but certainly not least, as you navigate the reasons why you feel like you’re eating large amounts of food, treat yourself with compassion. Compulsive eaters can be excessively self-critical (I know this, because I was like that too back when I was dieting) and you are worthy of your own compassion.

I hope this exhaustive list of reasons for eating large amounts of food helps you feel more normal — because it’s quite likely that you just haven’t been eating enough and/or you’ve been dieting too restrictively. Giving yourself some grace can make a huge difference.

Why Am I Eating So Much Food? The Answer Is Unique for Everyone

Understanding why we may find ourselves eating large amounts of food is a complex interplay of psychology and physiology. While biology certainly plays a role, it is often our psychological triggers that dominate our eating patterns.

Instead of labeling ourselves as simply eating too much, it’s important to use curiosity and compassion when approaching the question of, Why am I eating so much? We need to recognize that our bodies have natural hunger cues and dietary needs that should not be ignored.

Listening to our bodies, fueling ourselves adequately, and practicing the Stop, Drop, & Feel can help us establish a healthier relationship with food; one where we no longer feel out of control around food, but instead we feel deeply in sync with our bodies.

If those goals sound nice, then you’ll LOVE my free ebook below! It digs deep into the psychology of overeating:

  1. Ledoux, S et al. “Associated factors for self-reported binge eating among male and female adolescents.” Journal of adolescence vol. 16,1 (1993): 75-91. doi:10.1006/jado.1993.1006
  2. Johannsen, Darcy L et al. “Metabolic slowing with massive weight loss despite preservation of fat-free mass.” The Journal of clinical endocrinology and metabolism vol. 97,7 (2012): 2489-96. doi:10.1210/jc.2012-1444
  3. Gavrieli, A et al. “Effect of different amounts of coffee on dietary intake and appetite of normal-weight and overweight/obese individuals.” Obesity (Silver Spring, Md.) vol. 21,6 (2013): 1127-32. doi:10.1002/oby.20190
  4. Dorling, James et al. “Acute and Chronic Effects of Exercise on Appetite, Energy Intake, and Appetite-Related Hormones: The Modulating Effect of Adiposity, Sex, and Habitual Physical Activity.” Nutrients vol. 10,9 1140. 22 Aug. 2018, doi:10.3390/nu10091140
  5. Samra RA. Fats and Satiety. In: Montmayeur JP, le Coutre J, editors. Fat Detection: Taste, Texture, and Post Ingestive Effects. Boca Raton (FL): CRC Press/Taylor & Francis; 2010. Chapter 15. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK53550/
  6. Groesz, Lisa M et al. “What is eating you? Stress and the drive to eat.” Appetite vol. 58,2 (2012): 717-21. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2011.11.028
  7. Yau, Y H C, and M N Potenza. “Stress and eating behaviors.” Minerva endocrinologica vol. 38,3 (2013): 255-67.
  8. Mattes, Richard D. “Hunger and thirst: issues in measurement and prediction of eating and drinking.” Physiology & behavior vol. 100,1 (2010): 22-32. doi:10.1016/j.physbeh.2009.12.026
  9. Pradhan, Geetali et al. “Ghrelin: much more than a hunger hormone.” Current opinion in clinical nutrition and metabolic care vol. 16,6 (2013): 619-24. doi:10.1097/MCO.0b013e328365b9be
  10. Greer, Stephanie M et al. “The impact of sleep deprivation on food desire in the human brain.” Nature communications vol. 4 (2013): 2259. doi:10.1038/ncomms3259
  11. Ramachandran, A. “Know the signs and symptoms of diabetes.” The Indian journal of medical research vol. 140,5 (2014): 579-81.
  12. Amin, Anjali et al. “The central effects of thyroid hormones on appetite.” Journal of thyroid research vol. 2011 (2011): 306510. doi:10.4061/2011/306510

Keep It Going: Get "The Spiritual Seeker's Guide to Stop Binge Eating" (Free Ebook)

The Spiritual Seeker's Guide to Stop Binge Eating

The Spiritual Seeker’s Guide to Stop Binge Eating will show you even more insight into the subconscious reasons why we eat past fullness — even when we really don’t want to! (It’s a free, 13-page, beautifully-illustrated PDF.)

When you sign up, you’ll also get a free 5-part crash course in Psycho-Spiritual Wellness to catch you up to speed. It’s perfect if you’re new to my blog. Sign up below:

You're On a Roll: Take the Eating Psychology QUIZ!

Even if you struggle with overeating, I bet I can guess your strength around food.

If you think food is your weakness, take the quiz and give me the chance to change your mind. There are just 8 questions.

Once you finish, you can either skip the email part (because I hate quizzes that force you to enter one!) or you can sign up to get a free 5-day crash course on Psycho-Spiritual Wellness. It’s perfect for beginners!

You're Really on a Roll: Get a Handle on Self-Sabotage

Bestseller: Why We Do the Things We Do

If you’re ready to take things even deeper, check out my most popular workbook, Why We Do the Things We Do: A Workbook to Curb Self-Sabotage.

By actually putting pen to paper, you’ll be surprised by what comes up. This is how you can discover your unique psychological blocks to compulsive eating.

I swear by workbooks!!! There is something about separating our thoughts onto paper that allows us to dig DEEP at our subconscious blocks around food and weight.

If you like everything you’ve read so far, this is the perfect place to make massive progress. (It’s my bestseller, after all!)

Since you're here, I would LOVE it if you dropped a comment on this post.

I read and reply to every single one! Just like I do with my emails. Since I don’t use much social media (outside of Pinterest and YouTube), I very much enjoy this opportunity to hear your thoughts and connect ✨

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *